Who didn’t know that on Friday when the CJ Abrams news of a position change was announced that it was going to take on a life of its own? After manager Blake Butera discussed it briefly at his pregame media session on Friday, all of the context into many of the quotes by both Butera and Abrams turned into opinion pieces. Most pointed at the team doing CJ wrong.

If the team proactively had foreseen this was going to head into negativity, which they should have in my humble opinion, the team could have done an informal media session with team president, Paul Toboni, Butera, and Abrams in the dugout to break the news and let the media ask questions on Friday. This is known as a united front. Instead, Butera spoke to the media and broke the news himself. They let this sit and allowed the narrative to take-off, and it turned into a PR mess with all of the negativity.

At the very least, Toboni could have jumped in immediately after The Athletic article that made things worse due to those who did not read the article and just went with the title of “CJ Abrams ‘not thrilled’ with change, agent says.” The full quote was actually very telling in the context that I read it, “I think, first, CJ was not thrilled about the decision to move him off shortstop at this time,” Abrams’ agent, Mike Sanders of Roc Nation Sports, told The Athletic. “But his priority is to win games for the Nationals and to be a team-first player, so that is what he’s going to do.”

On the surface, that full-quote is not earth shattering, but when you just focus on the title and see ‘not thrilled’ without reading the article, that could lead some straight into the negative abyss.

Finally today, Toboni on the Sports Junkies radio show on 106.7 The Fan, jumped right into it. Toboni was asked if this was going to cause a ❝divorce❞ with the team and Abrams, and Toboni was too kind on his answer and should have called BS on it as he said people are ❝throwing opinions out there.❞ Instead Toboni remained calm and said ❝I can understand how that narrative could get out there — BUT not close to the vibe that has actually taken place.❞ Toboni clearly was not happy about the BS he’s read, but he didn’t name specifics. @JunksRadio said the perception is that ❝[CJ] is pissed.❞

Toboni added that ❝CJ has been freaking awesome like when we had those meetings he’s been great and asked the right questions, and I think he’s understood everything. … How he’s handled being upset has been great.❞

Toboni added this is ❝about the team — it’s about the Nationals.❞ My thinking is that this is more that they wanted the trade deadline to pass and see how CJ does at second base and Nasim Nunez at shortstop. If neither works, they know the next step might be the outfield. Let’s hope it works for both players.

Here is what Butera said when he broke the news on Friday, August 14:

“Ultimately, this is a decision that Paul [Toboni], Ani [Kilambi] and myself decided to make, and CJ was on board with it, which makes it easier to kind of lay it all out for him.”

“Obviously, CJ spent the majority of his career at shortstop and all of his time for the Nationals there. So I understand this is not an easy decision, not an easy conversation, of course. But ultimately, we felt like this was the best thing for the team going forward.”

“I think if CJ plays a good second base and Nasim Nuñez plays a great shortstop, I think we’re a better team.”

“We’re thinking about all those things, we are, but ultimately right now, what we’re trying to do is do what’s best for this team and this organization to win as many games as possible the rest of this year, and also set ourselves up for next year. But we’re taking all those things into account when we’re making decisions like this.”

— Nats’ manager Blake Butera said about the move

Switching Abrams to a new position is due to his declining defense to the worst in baseball in terms of OAA and errors. This should not have been a surprise to anyone except the timing of the announcement. The day before when talking about the goals to accomplish in the final 40-games of the season we had a paragraph on a position switch for Abrams. We didn’t know the next day that the team would announce it.

A public relations strategy should almost always be proactive when sharing news that will most certainly trend into negativity. Moving proactively helps you control the story, set the facts straight, and show that you take responsibility before rumors start. This would also set a united front. Instead Butera unilaterally broke the news.

Why Being Proactive Works:

  • Control the story: You share the truth before people guess or spread fake news
  • Build trust: People respect team leaders who faces hard facts early
  • Lower the shock: Early warnings give the public time to process the news
  • Stop rumors: Quick facts leave no room for fake news to grow

After Friday’s game, Abrams was bombarded with questions by the media about Butera’s announcement of the move. His public comments of course felt like he was disappointed with the decision. But disappointment should not be confused with not being a team player which is how we see this with Abrams being a team-first player.

We used that exact “team-first” wording to describe CJ on Saturday, and coincidentally Abrams’ agent said the same on Monday in The Athletic article, “his priority is to win games for the Nationals and to be a team-first player.”

When you spend your entire career at a key position, and get voted by the fans to the All-Star starter at that position, this is much more than an ego hit — this will take time to process. That is normal. Abrams has accepted the move with his bosses. And a key point is that Abrams is not inserting himself as a ‘me first’ player. As Butera said, “CJ was on board with it.”

“Not too many thoughts [about the position change]. I stay present, for real.”

“Just go over there and be athletic. There’s a shorter throw, it’s pretty much the only difference. You have different pivots you have to do at second base. But other than that, it’s still the [middle] infield.”
 
“That’s just where I’ve been playing my whole life, and I believe I can be a great shortstop.”

— Abrams said to the media on Friday about the position move

With all of that, Butera said that Abrams will move over to second base and today could be that day. Abrams will still play some games at shortstop when Nunez is not out there. But Abrams’ primary position moving forward is second base. Abrams is under team-control through the 2028 season. By that point in time, who knows what the roster will look like. Will this ultimately end in divorce? That sounds overly dramatic. They aren’t moving Abrams to full-time DH.

The last time the team had a PR disaster like this was of course when the Washington Post reported that Abrams was being shopped for a trade, and Toboni addressed that as fake news and called out the Washington Post. And with fake news, they could have addressed it sooner as they led that story fester for several days.

The PR disaster before that was the Stephen Strasburg retirement story. They sat on that until former-GM Mike had his next scheduled radio show, and he addressed it at that point but several days had passed and the damage was done. The bridge between Strasburg and the team still feels like it has been burned — and in desperate need of a reconciliation.

You would think that in the future the best way to address these issues is by hitting it straight on to not allow several days to pass. But on this Abrams position move, the Nats had the ability to address it as a united front, and they chose not to do that. That’s where I will give an E-6.

Photo by Marideth Sandler/Nats.Talk

Leave a Reply

“I said that my goal is to make the Nationals the envy of sport.”

“To me, that means an organization defined by our relentless pursuit of excellence, strengthened by our connection to each other and fueled by our positive energy. As a result, we become an organization that players and staff are itching to join because they know it’s where they will develop and thrive most; a place that energizes our loyal fans and attracts new ones, and where success is achieved – and sustained – over time.”

~ Paul Toboni
If the link for the slide below has an option to buy, you can navigate to other products on that site and we will still get a credit.

Dylan Crews Clearance
MLB Shop

Dylan Crews Clearance

previous arrow
next arrow

Designed with WordPress